Help · Methodology

The survivor scenario (widow's penalty)

From RangefinderInvest's built-in help · applies to version 0.59.3

For a couple, the riskiest tax event in the plan is often one nobody prices: the first death. The survivor scenario models it as a deterministic what-if at an age you choose, not a mortality prediction.

From the chosen age, five things change at once:

  • The survivor files Single: the standard deduction and bracket widths roughly halve, so the same income lands in higher brackets. This is the widow's penalty.
  • Social Security becomes one benefit: at each age you receive the larger of the benefits in payment, either your own or your spouse's from the age they planned to claim it. Two benefits never stack. Whichever is being paid at the death carries on until a larger one starts. That works in both directions: your own smaller benefit can step up to your spouse's larger one when they would have claimed it, or your spouse's smaller benefit can carry you until your own larger one starts.
  • A working spouse's contributions and pay stop. The plan models you as the survivor, so the first death is your spouse's.
  • Spending drops to your survivor percentage. ~75% is the convention because fixed costs don't halve when the household does. Two costs are not scaled by it: a mortgage payment (a contract does not shrink), and a pre-65 marketplace premium, where only your own share is owed from the death and that share is charged in full. The ACA income limit becomes a one-person household's limit then too (see the ACA model).
  • The tax-deferred balance re-bases onto the survivor's own RMD schedule.

The survivor chart shows the squeeze year by year: income halves while the tax bill climbs, which is exactly why couples often convert to Roth while both are alive and filing jointly. The same conversion costs materially more tax once the survivor files Single.

Deliberately deterministic: you pick the age and see the consequences, rather than averaging over mortality tables where the penalty would blur into the fan. Try a few ages; the shape of the answer is the point.