Help · Methodology

How Roth conversions are modeled

From RangefinderInvest's built-in help · applies to version 0.59.3

A Roth conversion moves dollars from tax-deferred to Roth, paying ordinary tax now to shrink RMDs and future tax later. The projection models them year by year, inside the full tax picture.

Two strategies

  • Fill to a ceiling. Each year, convert just enough to bring ordinary income up to a chosen ceiling, such as a tax-bracket top or a Medicare IRMAA MAGI cliff. Automatically heavy in low-income years and light (or skipped) when RMDs and other income already fill the bracket. Ceilings are phased: target a low bracket early, a higher one later, stop at a chosen age.
  • Custom amounts. Explicit dollar phases you set per age range.

Details that change the answer

  • Conversions are taxed as ordinary income and funded per your draw order. To keep living expenses from eating the bracket headroom, put Roth ahead of tax-deferred in the draw order for the phase covering your conversion years. The plan never switches the order for you.
  • If you're on a marketplace health plan, the ACA cliff is usually the binding ceiling before 65. One converted dollar too many can cost a whole year's subsidy.
  • Conversions shrink future RMDs and move growth into tax-free Roth. They are taxed at your filing status's brackets (single or married-filing-jointly).
  • The with-vs-without comparison shows exactly the RMD and tax stream a conversion plan erases, alongside lifetime tax and ending value. The no-conversion baseline is taxed the same way as the plan.

The optimizer's frontier re-runs the same engine over a grid of ceilings on identical seeded paths, so differences between candidates are real, not luck.

Explore's Roth conversion optimizer sweeps the fill level of the plan you set in Money flow and ranks the candidates by plan success. The ACA Roth top-up is a separate strategy that stays on in every row, so with it on the first row reads No conversion beyond the ACA top-up and shows what the top-up converted. Conversions run in the low-income years before RMDs begin (at your RMD start age, see RMDs).

The optimizer sweeps the window from your start age to the conversion stop age. If the stop age is not later than the start age (for example a household already past the RMD age), it says so instead of running: an empty window converts nothing, and Apply does not write a plan it could not score. A blank stop age is the default, eight years past your current age.

The sweep runs in the background, one candidate after another: the button counts them as they finish and Cancel stops it. A cancelled sweep shows nothing; editing the plan or leaving the page cancels it too.