Help · Methodology

How a withdrawal is funded

From RangefinderInvest's built-in help · applies to version 0.59.3

Withdraw mode turns "I need $X" into a funding plan: which accounts and holdings supply the cash, in what order, and what it costs in tax. You pick the strategy; the engine builds the orders. The strategy picked here is this session's choice. The saved defaults it starts from (default strategy, reserve floor, equity drawdown band) live in the Options drawer beside these controls; Make this my default is the only thing that changes the saved strategy, so picking one to try never silently overwrites it.

The Options drawer used to be a Settings section; it moved here, next to the plan it configures, because none of its three knobs is a fact about you. The reserve floor and equity drawdown band save as you change them, each on its own field; Make this my default and those two fields are protected writes and close once a commercial trial ends, while the strategy picker beside them stays live because choosing a strategy for one withdrawal writes nothing.

  • Trim overweight: sell what you're over-target, so the withdrawal doubles as a rebalance. Natural when markets are up.
  • Cash & fixed income first: spend cash, then maturing bills/CDs, leaving equities untouched. Natural when equities are down. A bill or CD counts as maturing only if its maturity is still ahead of you and within a year: on or before the same date next year, so a 52-week bill bought today counts. One that has already matured, or whose maturity date the app can't read, is marked Reconcile, because the broker has probably swept it to cash already and your ledger hasn't caught up.
  • Proportional: sell everything pro-rata, keeping the allocation.
  • Income first: accrued cash and money-market balances before any invested principal.

Within a strategy, orders run in tax-aware account order: taxable first, tax-deferred next, then Roth, and tax-exempt (HSA, 529) last. Least tax-advantaged dollars go first so the sheltered ones keep compounding; an HSA is the last balance a plan should spend, not the first. Only accounts with both their Rebalance and Withdrawals flags on participate. "Overweight" is measured against targets sized to the post-withdrawal portfolio as the plan actually leaves it: each account's targets shrink by the amount the tax-ordered plan takes from that account, not by an even share of the withdrawal. A withdrawal the taxable account can fund alone is sized against the taxable account alone, so its trims bring it back to its model and Drift after reads zero, instead of selling a sleeve that was already underweight. Draws and targets are solved together; in the rare case where several accounts of one tax type keep trading the draw back and forth, Drift after says how far the targets may be off.

Before asking for or interpreting an amount, Withdraw checks the selected scope. No eligible account routes to Accounts to enable both flags; a missing or dangling model assignment routes to Accounts; an invalid current allocation routes to Allocation models; no holding or cash balance routes to Holdings; and held rows with no usable value route to Settings → Price data. An ordinary positive-weight slice needs a positive-weight fund to be executable, and a fund line with a share needs a ticker, while ladder and self-directed slices may intentionally be fundless. This keeps a missing prerequisite from becoming a false Enter an amount result.

The tax estimate

Security sales in a taxable account walk your real lots by your chosen lot method (HIFO by default), split gains short- vs. long-term, and apply the flat assumed rates from your Household profile. This is an estimate, not a tax return. The Gain / loss $ column reads a gain in green with a plus and a loss in red with a minus; hover it for the short- and long-term split. Loss sales are flagged as Harvest; a harvest is warned as a wash sale if the same ticker was bought within ±30 days in any account, including reinvested dividends. Only a purchase counts: shares moved in kind between accounts, a position already held when tracking began, and a share count Reconcile corrected were not bought on that date, so they never raise the warning. A sale at a net gain is not flagged as a wash sale, in Withdraw mode or on the Rebalance Planner's trade checks: only a loss is disallowed, and the estimate does not examine loss lots inside a sale that nets to a gain. A money-market or bill draw reads Reduce, like every other order.

Selling inside a tax-deferred account, a Roth, or a tax-exempt HSA/529 is not a taxable event, so those orders show $0 and carry no harvest or wash-sale flag, because there is no loss to disallow. They show $0 even with no cost basis loaded, where a taxable sale would show an unavailable estimate. A taxable sale also shows an unavailable estimate when the lots that are loaded fall short of the shares being sold: a partly imported position would otherwise quote the tax on the covered fraction as though it were the tax on the sale. What this figure does not cover is the tax on the distribution itself: money taken out of a tax-deferred account is ordinary income in the year you take it. That belongs to the plan, not the trade. See the draw order.

Flagged rows are also collected in an expandable Wash-sale review that names the account and ticker. The table pins account identity left and Action / order right, so the funding instruction remains readable at the app's minimum width.

Now or defer

Rebalance now adds the trades that restore the model at the new, smaller size. Defer leaves the drift standing. The page tells you how far equities sit from target, and the correction resurfaces at your next contribution or scheduled rebalance.