Help · Methodology

How to read the results

From RangefinderInvest's built-in help · applies to version 0.59.3

The projection runs your plan a thousand times over different market sequences. Here is what each number it reports back is actually claiming.

Success %

The share of runs that funded every obligation all the way to your end age: spending, one-time expenses, income tax, and insurance premiums alike. A single unfunded dollar in a single year fails that whole run.

So it is a pass/fail tally, not a margin of safety. It says nothing about how the failures failed. That is why the next number exists.

In the strip at the top of the Retirement plan, a model's success rate is green from 90%, plain from 75% and red below 75%. Those are cut-offs, not a verdict: 75.0% and 74.0% are the same kind of plan, and hovering a column says so.

Failure depth

When runs do fail, the app also reports the typical depletion age and the total shortfall, measured across the failing runs only. Two plans can both succeed 85% of the time and be nothing alike: one runs a little short at 93, the other is empty at 78. Read the pair together, never the success rate alone.

The median and the bands

The median is the middle outcome. Half the runs did better, half worse. It is not a forecast, and no single year of it is a promise.

Turn on the probability fan and you see the spread around it:

  • The 25–75 band is the everyday range: half of all runs landed inside it.
  • The 10–90 band is the stretch: falling outside it is about a 1-in-10 result, in either direction.

The 90% downside readout states that lower edge as one number: the 10th-percentile ending value, or, once more than 10% of runs fail, the age by which that run is out of money.

Confidence by age

The success rate is one number for the whole plan. Under the fan, the app also reports how that confidence should change as you get through your early retirement years: for each age, the share of outcomes that reach it on track and go on to fund everything. See confidence by age.

Per-age numbers are medians too

Every column of the year-by-year table is the median for that age, taken across all runs. Neighboring rows can come from different runs, so they do not add up the way one household's actual years would.

To follow a single coherent path instead, zero the volatility inputs. The Trace: zero volatility button does it in one click, and the medians collapse onto that one path exactly. See why re-running gives the same answer.

Reading the year-by-year table

The Detail section's Year-by-year detail table gives the median flows and balances by age, in today's dollars. It reads left to right the way a year actually happens:

  • Balances · start of year. What you hold at the start of the year: Value is the total, with the bucket balances (taxable, tax-deferred, Roth, HSA) beside it.
  • Money out. Spend is what the plan actually spent that year; Medicare has its own column beside it and is not inside it. Plan, when it appears, is the spending schedule you typed in. It only shows when it disagrees with Spend, because your spending policy moved spending away from the schedule. One-time and Tax follow. With a home purchase, Spend switches from your rent to ownership plus the declining-real mortgage at the buy year, and One-time includes the down payment. With extra principal payments or a payoff it includes those too, at the amounts you planned rather than the cash the simulation confirmed it funded.
  • Funded by. Income, the forced RMD, and the From … columns are the spending and one-time draw out of each bucket. The tax-deferred draw excludes the forced RMD, which is shown on its own. Withdrawal % is every dollar the portfolio paid out as a share of start-of-year Value: those draws, plus the RMD (less the excess RMD reinvested into taxable), plus both HSA draws, plus the dollars that funded the year's tax. It is the running draw rate: it drifts up in down years and falls once Social Security starts. See the withdrawal-rate check. The table's last row is your end age: the plan records your balances there and stops, so no year is simulated at it, and Spend, RMD and Withdrawal % show a dash there. The RMD panel lists the simulated years only.
  • Into accounts. Contributions and Roth conversions.

Every column is its own median across the simulated outcomes, so the columns need not add across a row. Columns with no activity anywhere in the plan are hidden and listed under the table.

Three columns appear only when the plan uses them. From HSA (med) is the tax-free qualified-medical draw (it displaces spend rather than adding to it); From HSA (other) is a non-medical draw, ordinary income at 65 and over. ACA is one signed column: a positive figure is the subsidy value you kept that year (you paid the net premium); a negative figure is a subsidy lost that year (you paid the full premium, the subsidy added back to spending).

For a single path you can reconcile by hand, press Trace: zero volatility, or zero the volatility inputs yourself. While tracing, every volatility is forced to 0 and the table is one deterministic path; Restore volatility puts your settings back. See why re-running gives the same answer.

The lifetime spending chart

The Expenses section's Lifetime spending projection draws spending by category for each year, in today's dollars, with your total income traced as the dashed line. Hover any year for the split and that year's withdrawal rate.

Read the stack in two parts. The four recurring bands (Recurring, Housing, Medical and Medicare) are the median-total year's own split, and they sum to that median total. One-time shows the costs you planned and Taxes is its own median, so the stack as a whole is not one sampled outcome.

Spending starts at the plan's first spending phase, which the Retire at age box and that phase keep in step. If you are already at or past that age, the box reads Now (spending begins today) with a Change link to set a different age. A plan that is still working therefore draws nothing before that age, and the chart carries a "Working years" note that names the age spending starts instead of leaving the gap unexplained. The Income chart carries the same note, because its dashed spending line is empty over the same years. Neither chart invents spending for the working years.

The money-flow chart

The Retirement plan's Money flow, by age chart shows money flowing into your accounts (above the line) against money flowing out of them (below), colored by account. Both halves share one dollar scale and one step, with the zero line labelled $0. The net line is money in minus money out, your real portfolio depletion. Transfers such as Roth conversions and reinvested RMDs appear on both sides and cancel in the net, and taxes show on hover. Each year is one outcome's own flows, the one whose net change is the middle one (see the Retirement plan page), so the bars, the net line and the underlying flows add up. Small individual lines at or below $0.50 in today's dollars are omitted from Year detail, so its total and net can differ slightly from the time chart.

The single-year view shows one year in detail: sources on the left flow through your accounts to uses on the right, with ribbon width proportional to dollars. Ribbons and hover details below $0.50 in the selected display dollars are hidden; this does not change its totals. Scrub the year with the slider. With a financed home, the draws already include your mortgage's funded extra principal and any payoff. They leave through the same accounts as any other draw, not as a second outflow.

The mortgage group

A financed home adds two more readouts, beyond the ordinary numbers above.

The Housing panel shows two halves. Planned is a deterministic amortization run once at your assumed inflation, treating every entered payment as fully funded: when the loan ends, total contract interest, and interest saved by any extra principal or an early payoff. Simulation is what the thousand runs actually did with that schedule: the age the loan is repaid (median and the 10th to 90th range), the share of paths that repay it at all, and each payment's own eligible and fully-funded share. See extra principal payments for the full methodology.

Detail's mortgage columns are independent per-path medians of the simulated loan, not one path's statement, and they sit beside the deterministic Plan column. They split the same note into stocks and flows. Opening and closing balance are stocks: what the note owes at a point in time. They are read at different deflators, opening at that year's own and closing at the next year's, because closing balance is the next row's own opening. Interest, scheduled principal, extra principal (funded), payoff principal, payoff interest and unfunded paydown requests are flows: what moved during that year. In the loan's final year a flow is only the months the loan actually ran, not a full year's worth.

Unfunded paydown requests is counted request by request: each planned extra payment or payoff asks for the principal owed at its own month, and the column adds up whatever the portfolio could not deliver. A later request, a payoff above all, asks again for principal an earlier one left unpaid, so the column can add up to more than the loan ever owed. It tells you how much of your paydown plan went undelivered, not how much is still owed; the principal still owed is the closing balance. The shortfall total counts the same requests the same way.

The ordinary installment is treated as a contract: it is deemed paid ahead of other recurring spending on every simulated outcome, whatever else that year's budget cannot cover, so the note keeps amortizing on schedule. That simplification is made visible, not hidden, through two diagnostics beside the mortgage group: funded non-mortgage (how much of what a path actually funded went to spending other than the installment) and installment gap (how much of the installment itself that funded spending did not cover). A shortfall here shows up as a cut to your OTHER spending, never as a missed mortgage payment: there is no arrears state, so nothing carries forward with penalty interest.

When the three models disagree, the disagreement is the finding: it tells you the answer depends on which market history you believe, which is worth more than any single success rate.