Help · Methodology

How the HSA is modeled

From RangefinderInvest's built-in help · applies to version 0.59.3

The projection treats an HSA as its own fourth bucket with the tax shape that makes HSAs unusual: deductible going in, tax-free coming out for medical costs, ordinary income otherwise after 65.

While working

Your Household profile's HSA contribution flows in annually from your paycheck (today's dollars) while a salary is being earned. It reduces income tax and FICA. It is the one account that escapes both, and contributions stop when Medicare starts, because Medicare enrollment ends HSA eligibility. The plan enrolls you at 65, from the first day of your birthday month, so the year you turn 65 keeps the months before it: born in October, nine twelfths of that year's contribution. That only matters if you keep working past 65. The plan does not model delaying Medicare while you work. It's modeled as one household HSA tied to earnings; direct contributions outside a paycheck aren't separately modeled.

The annual limit follows your age as the plan runs, not just your age today: the extra $1,000 catch-up appears in the year you turn 55, and the contribution stops at your 65th birthday month. The same is true of your 401(k) limit: the age-50 catch-up and the larger one for ages 60 to 63 switch on and off on the right birthdays.

In retirement

The HSA sits outside the normal draw order:

  • Qualified medical spending draws from the HSA first, tax-free. Each year's medical expense line is paid from the HSA while it lasts, displacing withdrawals the other accounts would have made. Left on auto, that line is your out-of-pocket medical before 65 and the base Medicare Part B/D premium after. The year you turn 65 is split at your birthday month, the same split the plan uses to bill Medicare. Born in December, that year counts eleven months of out-of-pocket and one month of Medicare.
  • Non-medical HSA draws are a last resort: allowed from 65 (taxed as ordinary income, like a traditional IRA), used only when every other bucket is exhausted.
  • The year's income tax can come out of the HSA once every other bucket is empty, at any age. Before 65 that is a non-qualified distribution, which the IRS taxes as income plus a 20% additional tax. The plan charges neither on a tax payment, as it does not re-tax any tax payment. That is a deliberate simplification. It only reaches a path that has already run everything else dry, and it keeps that path going a little longer than it would.

Where the HSA shows up on the charts

Because HSA money pays for spending like any other account, it is counted like any other account. The Lifetime income projection's Savings drawdown band includes both kinds of HSA draw, so the stack explains the whole of what the year cost. Leaving them out made a fully funded plan read as short by exactly what the HSA paid, every year the HSA was paying it.

The year-by-year table keeps them apart in their own columns, From HSA (med) and From HSA (other), when you want to see which door the money came out of.

What this implies

An HSA outlasting your medical costs is fine. The surplus behaves like extra tax-deferred savings. The "HSA at longevity" figure on the Retirement plan is that surplus: what's left after lifetime medical spending has been funded tax-free.

The model doesn't track receipts-in-a-shoebox reimbursement strategies or per-state HSA tax quirks. This is a deliberate simplification.